top of page
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • X

Search Results

Search this site

356 results found with an empty search

  • Les églises appellent à nouveau à l'action sur la guerre entre la Russie et l'Ukraine

    Deux ans après l'invasion massive de l'Ukraine par la Russie, les dirigeants des églises canadiennes continuent de prier et d'appeler à l'action. Quarante-cinq d'entre eux, dont de nombreux dirigeants affiliés à l’AEC, ont publié une déclaration commune avant l'anniversaire de l'invasion en février. Phil Wagler est l'agent de liaison mondial de l'AEC. « Le corps de Christ a pour mission d'être une communauté de paix et de réconciliation dans un monde chaotique », explique-t-il. Cette collaboration de la famille chrétienne canadienne est un appel à vivre cet appel pour la guérison des nations. » Les signataires ont encouragé la tenue d'une journée de prière et de commémoration le 24 février, la poursuite des prières pour la paix en Ukraine et dans le monde, le soutien aux réfugiés ukrainiens, la prise de mesures diplomatiques en vue d'une paix juste et durable, l'établissement de relations de collaboration et le maintien de l'espoir d'une réconciliation. Une partie de la déclaration pastorale se lit comme suit : « Sans minimiser de quelque manière que ce soit la souffrance et le chagrin causés par la guerre et la violence dans d’autres régions du monde, nous nous tenons ensemble pour inviter les chrétiens et toutes les personnes de bonne volonté à réfléchir de manière priante à la manière dont nous sommes tous appelés, et pouvons contribuer, à la réalisation de la paix en et pour l’Ukraine.» La déclaration a été préparée et approuvée par le Conseil canadien des églises, l’AEC et le Réseau Paix et Réconciliation de l'Alliance évangélique mondiale (M. Wagler en est le directeur mondial). Les 45 dirigeants canadiens qui l'ont signée sont issus des traditions orthodoxe, catholique, évangélique et d'autres traditions chrétiennes. « L'Ukraine est une région qui préoccupe beaucoup les Canadiens. Nous devons continuer à prier et à œuvrer pour la paix », déclare David Guretzki, président de l’AEC. Le document complet est disponible en anglais, en français ou en ukrainien sur le site TheEFC.ca/Statements.

  • Sur la colline du Parlement d'avril 2024

    Le point sur les questions les plus pressantes au Canada Retarder l'entrée en vigueur de l’aide médicale à mourir pour maladie mentale : Un projet de loi a été adopté pour retarder de trois ans, soit jusqu'en mars 2027, l'aide médicale à mourir pour maladie mentale. Le gouvernement a accordé ce sursit parce que plusieurs provinces, territoires et groupes d'experts ont déclaré que le système médical canadien n'était pas prêt pour l'aide médicale à mourir en cas de maladie mentale. Ce projet de loi exige également qu'un comité parlementaire examine l'admissibilité à l'AMM des personnes dont la seule condition médicale est la maladie mentale. L'examen de l'admissibilité débutera en 2026. Préjudices en ligne : Le gouvernement a déposé la Loi sur les préjudices en ligne le 26 février. Le projet de loi C-63 porte sur les contenus en ligne tels que les images d'abus sexuels d'enfants, les images intimes publiées sans consentement et la haine en ligne. L'AEC étudie ce projet de loi et s'exprimera à son sujet. Protéger les mineurs des contenus explicites en ligne : Un projet de loi visant à créer un délit pour la mise à disposition de pornographie en ligne à des mineurs à des fins commerciales est actuellement examiné par une commission parlementaire. Le projet de loi S-210 est étroitement axé sur les contenus sexuellement explicites et constituerait une étape importante pour limiter l'accès des mineurs à ces contenus en ligne. D'autres pays, comme l'Allemagne et le Royaume-Uni, ont mis en place une législation exigeant la vérification de l'âge pour les sites pornographiques en ligne. L'AEC préparera un rapport écrit à l'intention de la commission. Pour en savoir plus, consultez le site TheEFC.ca/S-210. Lutter contre la violence dans la prostitution : Dans une communication au rapporteur spécial des Nations Unies sur la violence à l'égard des femmes et des filles, l’AEC a souligné la violence inhérente à la prostitution et la manière dont elle est inextricablement liée à la traite des êtres humains et à d'autres formes d'exploitation sexuelle telles que la pornographie. La plupart des victimes de crimes liés à la prostitution au Canada sont des jeunes femmes, souvent issues de groupes à risque. Le rapport souligne que « la prostitution est un système d'exploitation qui repose sur des inégalités structurelles et de genre et qui exploite les vulnérabilités ». Il recommande que les lois canadiennes actuelles contre l'achat de services sexuels soient maintenues et appliquées, et que le Canada sensibilise à la loi et fournisse un financement pour les services de sortie. Pour en savoir plus, consultez le site TheEFC.ca/UN2024.

  • Letter on conscience to CPS Nova Scotia

    Dr. Gus Grant, Registrar College of Physicians & Surgeons of Nova Scotia 400-175 Western Parkway Bedford, NS B4B 0V1 Dear Dr. Grant, As Nova Scotia continues to develop policies and professional standards, we urge you to ensure robust conscience protection for physicians. The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada (EFC) is the national association of evangelical Christians in Canada. Established in 1964, the EFC provides a national forum for Canada’s four million Evangelicals and a constructive voice for biblical principles in life and society. The EFC has affiliated denominations, churches and organizations in Nova Scotia whose members include both physicians and patients in the NS healthcare system. Charter-protected freedoms of conscience and religion are fundamental freedoms that should be recognized and supported in College policies. These freedoms can be balanced with patients’ right to access care and, in fact, may allow for better patient care as patients have a greater degree of trust in physicians whose values align with their own. Conscience is rooted in the convictions and judgment of the individual physician. It is not the same for all physicians, even among those whose convictions are religiously informed. For example, there are evangelical and other physicians who are conscientious objectors to participating in the intentional ending of a patient’s life through medical assistance in dying (MAiD). Some medical professionals may not object to MAiD in principle but cannot end the life of a patient who still has decades to live. Others may not participate in ending the life of a patient who is eligible for MAiD but whose request is motivated by inadequate living conditions or lack of support. If MAiD continues to expand, such as on the basis of mental illness or to mature minors, there will be more medical professionals who will be unable to participate in MAiD. Health Canada’s Model Practice Standard for MAiD proposes use of the term “effective referral” in provincial regulators’ professional standards and policies related to MAiD. We urge you to respect and protect physicians deeply held beliefs and not compel direct or indirect participation in MAiD. Policies that require an effective referral for MAiD require physicians to actively facilitate procedures that may be against a physician’s conscience. This is unnecessary and problematic in many ways. An effective referral is understood as formal cooperation in the procedure. It acts as a professional recommendation that euthanasia should be considered and may take place. Participation in MAiD against their conscientious objection has a significant impact on a healthcare professional, including moral injury or moral distress. Objecting physicians may face burnout, early retirement or feel they need to leave their practice. This ultimately reduces the level of care available to patients. Protecting physicians’ conscience benefits patients as well. It fosters trust and open, honest communication. There are alternative ways for patients to access MAiD that do not violate a physician’s conscience or cause moral injury. Upon request, physicians could provide contact information or information on access routes to MAiD without being forced to participate in the delivery of the procedure. Many other provinces do not use the term “effective referral” in their policies, including BC, AB, SK, MB and NL. The Ontario College has revised its policy so that physicians may simply provide contact information in certain circumstances. Ensuring patient access does not need to violate physicians’ conscience. The Council of Canadians with Disabilities (CCD) has clearly advocated for robust conscience protection for healthcare professionals so that people with disabilities are able to find doctors they can trust as allies. As the CCD Ending of Life Ethics Committee wrote to Ontario Health Minister Elliott and PC MPPs on April 12, 2021: Given the ubiquity of medical ableism, it is of utmost importance that physicians and other healthcare providers whose views of the quality and worth of lives lived with disability differ from the majority be afforded robust protection of their conscience rights. People with disabilities need to be able to find doctors and other healthcare providers who they know will fight for their lives when necessary. Without legal protection of the conscience rights of healthcare professionals, this will not be possible. A failure to enact legislation to protect the conscience rights of healthcare professionals would thus leave thousands of Ontarians with disabilities without recourse to healthcare professionals who they can trust to serve as allies against the ubiquity of medical ableism that devalues and endangers their lives. All Nova Scotians would benefit from the ability to find physicians whose philosophy of care and convictions align with their own. We urge you to set a high standard of conscience protection as you develop and amend your policies and professional standards related to conscientious objection in Nova Scotia. Sincerely, Julia Beazley, Director of Public Policy Author: Julia Beazley

  • Churches speak out as Russia-Ukraine war enters 3rd year

    After two years of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Canadian church leaders continue to pray and call for action. A shared statement signed by 45 Canadian church leaders and ministry leaders, including many EFC affiliates, was released today. “Without in any way minimizing or ignoring the suffering and sorrow caused by war and violence in other areas of the world, we stand together in inviting Christians and all people of good will to prayerfully consider how we are all called, and might contribute to, the achievement of peace in and for Ukraine,” states one part of the document. Signatories are encouraging meaningful actions to foster peace, such as: Praying for peace in Ukraine and around the world; Building collaborative relationships; and Observing a day of prayer and remembrance on February 24. The pastoral statement was prepared and endorsed by The Canadian Council of Churches, The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada, and the Peace and Reconciliation Network of the World Evangelical Alliance. Signatories include Canadian leaders in Orthodox, Catholic, Evangelical and other faith traditions. >> Read the full document in English, French or Ukrainian

  • An important win in a long battle against MAiD's expansion

    We are so thankful to have good news to share about euthanasia laws in Canada! Let’s pause for a moment to be thankful and celebrate. It’s not the complete stop that we want and firmly believe should happen, but a delay of MAiD for mental illness means people in vulnerable moments will be better protected for a longer time. It’s at least a check to the momentum of rapid MAiD expansion. Here’s what’s happening Yesterday the committee studying medical assistance in dying (MAiD) recommended delaying MAiD for mental illness. In its report, the committee concluded that the medical system in Canada is not ready and recommended a delay. The committee held three days of hearings on the question of Canada’s readiness for expansion in November and December. They received hundreds of written submissions, including from the EFC. The EFC’s submission outlined reasons not to go ahead with euthanasia for mental illness, stating, “It is unconscionable that in Canada it may become easier for a person with mental illness to access MAID than the care and supports they need to live.” In response to the committee report, the Health and Justice Ministers say that the government agrees that the medical system isn’t ready and that they will introduce a bill to delay MAiD for mental illness in the coming days. As a CBC article reports, Health Minister Holland said, "The system needs to be ready and we need to get it right," he said. "It's clear from the conversations we've had that the system is not ready and we need more time." They didn’t give details about the delay, whether it would be an indefinite delay as the committee recommended, or a delay for a certain period of time. What’s ahead The time frame is short. If no bill is passed to make a change, MAiD for mental illness will become available on March 17, 2024. That leaves about a month and a half to pass legislation to delay, which is breakneck speed for Parliament. A bill to delay MAiD for mental illness will have to pass in both the House of Commons and the Senate. Many MPs seem open to delaying MAiD for mental illness. In fact, the bill to stop MAiD for mental illness altogether was defeated by a close vote last fall. It seems likely that a delay will pass in the House of Commons. If a bill to delay MAiD passes in the House of Commons, please contact your MP to say thank you. When we ask our MPs to hear our concerns and take action, it’s important to circle back and thank them for acting. It seems less clear what might happen when the bill reaches the Senate. The Senate has some strong pro-MAiD advocates. Because senators are appointed, they are not as concerned about the views of constituents. Please, join us in praying for senators to be willing to delay MAiD for mental illness. If you would like to pray for senators by name, you can find the senators from your province or region here. This good news of a delay comes after months of hard work. There have been many organizations (including the EFC), mental health professionals, doctors, lawyers - and individuals like you - who have called for a delay or a halt to MAiD for mental illness. We are so much more effective when we work together. Thank you to each and every one of you who contacted your MP and participated in EFC’s 10 days of action and It’s not too late campaigns. We’re grateful for your partnership and prayers.

  • 10 days of action on MAiD for mental illness

    The justice minister has suggested a delay of the March 17 implementation date might be possible. That would give more time to try to stop this misguided expansion. (Why? See TheEFC.ca/HaltMAID.) Please contact your MP in at least one way in the next 10 days to reach them before Parliament resumes Jan. 29. Step 1: Find your MP’s contact info using your postal code, www.ourcommons.ca/members/en. This site has the MP’s email, address and phone numbers for the MP’s local constituency office and Ottawa office. Step 2: Make contact with your MP in one of these ways: Call during office hours to leave a message with the MP’s staff Leave a voicemail outside of office hours Write an email or a letter. For greater impact, contact your MP in more than one way. For example, leave a phone message and then follow up with a short email. Or send an email and follow up with a phone call. Sample voicemail or phone conversation Hi, my name is ________. I live on ______ street, in _______ community. Thank you for serving our community. I’m calling because I’m really concerned about Medical Assistance in Dying for people with mental illness. This will put vulnerable people’s lives at risk. And it comes at a time when the health care system is under stress and people may have to wait months and years for treatment. I’ve heard the Justice Minister is considering a delay of MAID for mental illness. I want to ask our MP to support a delay of MAID for mental illness. Please let our MP know that I called. Sample email/letter to personalize Dear [MP’s name], Thanks for your work for our community. I am really concerned about Medical Assistance in Dying for people with mental illness. (personal story of someone who might be affected) This change will put vulnerable people at risk. It comes at a time when the health care system is under stress and there are long waiting lists for treatment. I’ve heard the Justice Minister is considering a delay of MAID for mental illness. Please support a delay. Sincerely, [your name and address] For more resources, including talking points and expert quotes on MAID for mental illness, see TheEFC.ca/HaltMAID.

  • Submission on conscience to CPS Alberta

    The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Alberta asked for feedback on its policy on conscientious objection by Jan. 15, 2024. One of the proposed changes introduces “effective referrals” into the policy. Many doctors object to ending the lives of their patients through euthanasia and would object to providing an effective referral for it. The EFC made a three-page submission, which you can download as a PDF.

  • Loving our neighbour through advocacy

    Why do we engage in policy discussions, as Christians? Politics is messy; it can be complex and sometimes dysfunctional, and sometimes it seems so hard to make a difference. But what the law says matters. Laws and policies affect how people are treated, what options they have or don’t have, who is protected, who is helped. When the Canada Summer Jobs program screens employers based on their beliefs, real ministries and organizations are excluded. Youth who would have been hired don’t get those jobs. Families and communities are affected when low-cost camps can’t care for as many children. Much-needed community programs suffer. When the prostitution law makes it illegal to buy sex or exploit others as a pimp, but makes those who are prostituted exempt from criminal charges, it protects the people who are most vulnerable in the situation. Prostitution is inherently exploitive. Canadians don’t enter prostitution out of an abundance of good options – they tend to have limited, or constrained choices. Those in prostitution tend to be younger, lower income, have a history of abuse, of time spent in foster care, among other vulnerabilities. When the law allows doctors to end the lives of people with disabilities who aren’t dying, or who are struggling with mental illness, it communicates that these lives aren’t worth living - particularly when eligibility for death is offered in the absence of support to live. Our hope is to bring biblical principles to these policy conversations. The gospel narrative sets out the value, worth and dignity of each human person. Advocating for good laws is one of the ways that we love our neighbour. Will you join us this year in praying and advocating for good laws and policies?

  • Letter to Canadian Human Rights Commission on religious intolerance

    Download a PDF of the joint four-page letter by Deina Warren, Director of Legal Affairs, The Canadian Centre for Christian Charities and Julia Beazley, Director of Public Policy, The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada

  • Letter on CASWLR to justice minister

    The Hon. Arif Virani Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada Dear Minister, We are writing to highlight the recent Ontario Superior Court of Justice decision in CASWLR v. Attorney General of Canada, which found all the provisions of Canada’s prostitution laws to be constitutional. The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada (EFC) acted as an intervener in this case in support of the Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act (PCEPA). We argued that buying sex is inherently exploitive and that the current laws protect human dignity and equality. The objectives of PCEPA, as laid out in the Attorney General of Canada’s factum in this case, are to “reduce the demand for prostitution with a view to discouraging entry into it, deterring participation in it and ultimately abolishing to the greatest extent possible, in order to protect communities, human dignity and equality.”[1] In this decision, Justice Goldstein found the prohibition against purchasing sexual services, which is the lynchpin of PCEPA, to be consistent with the objectives of the law. Justice Goldstein found that Parliament’s view of the harms of the sex trade is well grounded in the evidence (par. 384). He pointed to the evidence that significant numbers of sex workers come from marginalized and racialized groups – particularly Indigenous girls and women. He also pointed to evidence that sex work is highly gendered, with the overwhelming majority of sex workers being female and customers being male. And he found that violence and the threat of violence are present in the everyday lives of many sex workers. The EFC has long argued that violence is inherent to the system of prostitution itself. Justice Goldstein found that “violence is a feature, not a bug of sex work” (par. 216). We do not believe that violence can be reduced to acceptable levels. Justice Goldstein rejected the argument that PCEPA has led to an upsurge in violence against sex workers (par. 219). Rather, he pointed to the latest Juristat, which points to a significant decrease in homicide victims related to the sex trade after PCEPA came into force, despite overall homicides increasing.[2] It is simply not accurate to say that PCEPA has led to an increase in violence against sex workers. Justice Goldstein also found that “there is a clear link between sex work and human trafficking. In fact, there is a considerable body of evidence that many sex workers are manipulated or coerced into sex work or trafficked while in it” (par. 179). As the EFC and many others have consistently argued, while prostitution and sex trafficking are not the same, they are inextricably linked, and the demand for paid sex is the direct cause of commercial sexual exploitation of women and children. The question of choice in the system of prostitution is not straightforward. It is for this reason that our laws and policies related to prostitution must focus on the one party in the transaction that is certain to be making a free choice – the sex buyer. In focusing its attention on the sex buyer and on those third parties who would profit from the exploitation of others, PCEPA recognizes and responds to the difficulty of assessing and ensuring voluntariness within the system of prostitution. It seeks to “denounce and prohibit the demand for prostitution”[3] because it is the demand for paid sex that funnels women into prostitution and fuels sex trafficking. Our laws and policies must deal effectively with individual acts of exploitation, but also take into account the systemic nature of commercial sexual exploitation. The EFC has long argued prostitution is not merely a series of interactions between purchaser and purchased that exist independently of one another. Rather, prostitution is part of a system of exploitation that is based on structural inequalities and preys on vulnerabilities. While there are transactions within that system that may be consensual and non-coercive, these are nonetheless situated within a system of exploitation. PCEPA recognizes the systemic nature of prostitution and maintains that “the best way to avoid prostitution’s harms is to bring an end to its practice.”[4] In a submission to the Justice Committee during its review of PCEPA, the EFC wrote that education about the law would have helped Canadians, law enforcement, crown attorneys and others within the justice system, as well as those who are being prostituted, to understand what is legal and illegal, and the overall intent of PCEPA. The court noted there are significant misunderstandings about what the law allows and what it prohibits. Justice Goldstein found that: the Applicants’ evidence, especially the expert evidence, betrays a basic misunderstanding and misreading of the challenged offences. … sex workers should understand that PCEPA, properly interpreted, does not prohibit them from accessing safety measures, working in association with each other, and accessing the services of non-exploitive third parties. ... Sex workers should also understand that when PCEPA is properly interpreted, they can seek police assistance without fear that they will be charged for selling their sexual services, receiving a material benefit from the own sexual services, communicating with customers in relation to their own sexual services, or advertising in relation to their own sexual services. (par. 11) This misunderstanding of PCEPA is a failure of public education. One of the key elements of the Equality Model, after which PCEPA is modeled, is public education and awareness about the laws and their intent. We encourage the government to identify ways to raise awareness of PCEPA’s provisions. Justice Goldstein concluded that, overall, he finds that “Parliament’s response to a pressing and substantial concern is a carefully crafted legislative scheme that prohibits the most exploitive aspects of the sex trade while immunizing sex workers from prosecution.” As this case proceeds to the Ontario Court of Appeal, we urge your office to continue to vigorously defend the legislation. As well, we urge you to ensure consistent enforcement of PCEPA across Canada. We echo the Justice Committee recommendation that the government study how more consistent application of PCEPA could be encouraged across the country. Finally, we strongly recommend the government implement the third key element of the Equality Model, that is, sustained and significant funding for exit supports and services for individuals wishing to leave prostitution. Thank you for your work on behalf of all Canadians. Sincerely, Julia Beazley Director, Public Policy The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada [1] Factum of the Respondent, AG of Canada, in CASWLR v. Canada, at par.20 (a) [2] “Crimes related to the sex trade: Before and after legislative changes,” Statistics Canada, June 21, 2021, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/85-002-x/2021001/article/00010-eng.htm#r11 [3] https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/other-autre/protect/p1.html [4] https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/other-autre/protect/p1.html Author: Julia Beazley

  • Submission to Canada Summer Jobs study

    The EFC calls attention to significant problems with the Canada Summer Jobs program in a six-page submission to the Standing Committee on Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of People with Disabilities.The submission concludes: Canada Summer Jobs is a vital program that benefits many Canadians – the youth who are employed, the organizations that hire them and the communities they serve. Many faith-based organizations participate in the CSJ program and describe it as a welcome program that helps them serve their communities. At the same time, it is clear that there are significant problems with the program that must be addressed. We ask that the committee recommend the CSJ program follow the principles of transparency, procedural fairness and consistency. We ask that the committee recommend a careful consideration of the program’s compliance with Charter protections of conscience, religion, thought, belief, opinion and expression. We ask that applicants be considered on the basis of their activities and actions, and not be screened or excluded on the basis of beliefs. Download the submission: English / français (PDF).

  • Letter on MAiD expansion to three new ministers

    [ La version française suit ] The Hon. Arif Virani Minister of Justice The Hon. Mark Holland Minister of Health The Hon. Ya’ara Saks Minister of Mental Health and Addictions Dear Ministers, We offer our congratulations on your new portfolios. We appreciate that with these roles come additional responsibilities and commitments. We want to thank you for the work you do on behalf of all Canadians in these important areas. We are writing today out of our deep concern about Medical Assistance in Dying and the coming expansion to people with mental illness as their sole underlying medical condition in March 2024. Statistics Canada just released data that indicates more than 5 million Canadians met the criteria for a mental disorder in 2022. This study indicated a significant increase in Canadians experiencing mental disorders such as depression and anxiety. Among young women 15 to 24 years of age, the prevalence of major depressive disorder doubled from 2012 to 2022, and generalized anxiety disorder tripled. This expansion is set to come at a time when many Canadians who struggle with their mental health are unable to afford or access the mental health care they need, when they need it. Of those Canadians who met the criteria for a mental disorder, only half had spoken to a health professional about their mental health treatment that year, according to Statistics Canada. It is disturbing that 29% of Canadians now cite affordability as a reason not to access mental health services, up from 18%, according to Mental Health Research Canada polling. Testimony at the Special Joint Committee on MAID indicated waitlists for specialized mental health treatment can be months to years long. The assessment period for track two MAID is three months. The Prime Minister described Canada’s health care systems as “strained, if not broken right across the country in many, many ways” in a year end interview last year. To expand MAID eligibility further when the health care system is not functioning well seems particularly egregious. The MAID regime depends heavily on medical professionals’ subjective assessment, at a time when healthcare professionals are difficult to access and may not have adequate time with patients. This reality is even more concerning given the immense additional complexity of mental health. After the March 2024 expansion, what will be the safeguards for a severely depressed 18-year-old young woman who wants to end her life via MAID? We note that: There are no specific legislated safeguards for MAID for mental illness. There is no legal requirement that she has received treatment for a certain length of time, that she has received all reasonable treatment options, or even received any treatment. Unlike other jurisdictions which allow MAID for mental illness, she can refuse reasonable treatment that doctors believe may help and still be eligible for MAID. “Serious and irremediable” are very subjective, defined by the patient and the doctors who assess her. In its Final Report, the Expert Panel on MAID and Mental Illness commissioned by the government stated, “Because underlying pathology is unknown for the vast majority of mental disorders, incurable and irreversible are difficult terms to apply and are not commonly used in clinical practice when speaking about mental disorders. There is limited knowledge about the long-term prognosis for many conditions, and it is difficult, if not impossible, for clinicians to make accurate predictions about the future for an individual patient.” (emphasis added) One of the main reasons that a special committee on the evolution of the End-of-Life Care Act recommended to the National Assembly of Quebec last year that it not extend MAID to persons whose only medical condition is a mental disorder is the lack of consensus on incurability and irreversibility of decline. The committee explained its reasoning in this way, “Given the irremediable nature of medical aid in dying, the persistent doubts about the incurability of mental disorders lead us to exercise the greatest caution.” (p. 57) In fact, Quebec passed Bill 11 in June 2023 which specifically excludes a mental disorder, other than a neurocognitive disorder, as an illness for which a person can request MAID. This expansion will have the greatest impact on marginalized Canadians. The lives of people in vulnerable situations will be more at risk when Canadians become eligible for MAID on the basis of mental illness. Canadians who cannot afford or cannot access treatment will be more likely to request MAID. It should not be easier to obtain MAID than it is to obtain mental health care or other needed medical or social supports. MAID must not serve as Canada’s response to a lack of essential care and supports. It must not serve as Canada’s response to those who suffer. It is unconscionable that MAID will become available to Canadians whose very illnesses may include symptoms of despair, hopelessness, and a belief that their situation won’t change for the better; who have not tried all reasonable treatments or who may not have had access to treatment. We urge you to stop the expansion of MAID when mental illness is the sole medical condition, which will take effect in March 2024. Sincerely, Julia Beazley Director, Public Policy L'honorable Arif Virani Ministre de la Justice L'honorable Mark Holland Ministre de la Santé L'honorable Ya'ara Saks Ministre de la santé mentale et des toxicomanies Madame et Messieurs les ministres, Nous vous félicitons de votre nomination à vos nouveaux portefeuilles. Nous sommes conscients que ces fonctions s'accompagnent de responsabilités et d'engagements supplémentaires. Nous tenons à vous remercier pour le travail que vous accomplissez au nom de tous les Canadiens dans ces domaines importants. Nous vous écrivons aujourd'hui parce que nous sommes profondément préoccupés par l'aide médicale à mourir et par l'extension prochaine, dès mars 2024, de cette aide aux personnes dont la maladie mentale est la seule condition médicale sous-jacente. Statistique Canada vient de publier des données qui indiquent que plus de 5 millions de Canadiens répondaient aux critères d'un trouble mental en 2022. Cette étude indique une augmentation significative du nombre de Canadiens souffrant de troubles mentaux tels que la dépression et l'anxiété. Chez les jeunes femmes âgées de 15 à 24 ans, la prévalence du trouble dépressif majeur a doublé entre 2012 et 2022, et celle du trouble anxieux généralisé a triplé. Cette expansion interviendra à un moment où de nombreux Canadiens, aux prises avec des problèmes de santé mentale, n'ont pas les moyens d'accéder aux soins de santé mentale dont ils ont besoin, au moment où ils en ont besoin. Selon Statistique Canada, parmi les Canadiens qui répondaient aux critères d'un trouble mental, seule la moitié avait parlé à un professionnel de la santé de leur traitement de santé mentale cette année-là. Il est inquiétant de constater que 29 % des Canadiens citent désormais l'accessibilité financière comme raison de ne pas accéder aux services de santé mentale, alors qu'ils n'étaient que 18 % à le faire selon un sondage de Recherche en Santé Mentale Canada. Les témoignages recueillis par le Comité mixte spécial sur l’AMM indiquent que les listes d'attente pour un traitement spécialisé en santé mentale peuvent durer des mois, voire des années. La période d'évaluation pour la deuxième voie de l’AMM est de trois mois. L'année dernière, lors d'une interview de fin d'année, le Premier ministre a décrit les systèmes de soins de santé du Canada comme étant « mis à rude épreuve, voire brisés, à travers tout le pays, et ce, à de très nombreux égards ». Élargir encore l'admissibilité à l’AMM alors que le système de santé ne fonctionne pas bien semble particulièrement mal avisé. Le régime de l’AMM dépend fortement de l'évaluation subjective des professionnels de la santé, à un moment où ces derniers sont difficiles d'accès et n'ont pas toujours le temps de s'occuper des patients. Cette réalité est encore plus préoccupante compte tenu de l'immense complexité supplémentaire de la santé mentale. Après l'élargissement de mars 2024, quelles seront les garanties pour une jeune femme de 18 ans gravement déprimée qui souhaite mettre fin à ses jours par le biais de l’AMM? Nous constatons que : Il n'existe pas de garanties législatives spécifiques pour l'AMM en cas de maladie mentale. La loi n'exige pas qu'elle ait reçu un traitement pendant une certaine durée, qu'elle ait bénéficié de toutes les options de traitement raisonnables, ni même qu'elle ait reçu un quelconque traitement. Contrairement à d'autres juridictions qui autorisent l’AMM pour les maladies mentales, elle peut refuser un traitement raisonnable que les médecins estiment pouvoir l'aider et être quand même admissible à l’AMM. Les termes « grave et irrémédiable » sont très subjectifs, définis par le patient et les médecins qui l'évaluent. Dans son Rapport final, le groupe d'experts mandaté par le gouvernement pour faire rapport sur l’AMM et la maladie mentale a déclaré : « Puisque la pathologie sous-jacente est inconnue pour la grande majorité des troubles mentaux, les termes incurable et irréversible sont difficiles à appliquer et ne sont pas couramment utilisés dans la pratique clinique, lorsque l’on parle de troubles mentaux. Les connaissances sur le pronostic à long terme de nombreuses maladies sont limitées et il est difficile, voire impossible, pour les cliniciens de formuler des prévisions précises sur l’avenir d’un patient donné. (accentuation ajoutée) L'une des principales raisons pour lesquelles une commission spéciale sur l'évolution de la Loi concernant les soins de fin de vie a recommandé l'an dernier à l'Assemblée nationale du Québec de ne pas étendre l’AMM aux personnes dont la seule condition médicale est un trouble mental est l'absence de consensus sur l'incurabilité et l'irréversibilité du déclin. La commission a expliqué son raisonnement de la façon suivante : « Vu le caractère irrémédiable de l’aide médicale à mourir, les doutes persistants sur l’incurabilité des troubles mentaux nous amènent à faire preuve de la plus grande prudence. » (p. 59) En fait, le Québec a adopté en juin 2023 le projet de loi 11 qui exclut spécifiquement les troubles mentaux, autres que les troubles neurocognitifs, des maladies pour lesquelles une personne peut demander l'AMM. Cet élargissement aura le plus grand impact sur les Canadiens marginalisés. La vie des personnes en situation de vulnérabilité sera davantage menacée lorsque les Canadiens deviendront admissibles à l'AMM sur la base d'une maladie mentale. Les Canadiens qui n'ont pas les moyens ou l'impossibilité d'accéder à un traitement seront plus enclins à demander l'AMM. Il ne devrait pas être plus facile d'obtenir l’AMM que d'obtenir des soins de santé mentale ou d'autres soutiens médicaux ou sociaux nécessaires. L’AMM ne doit pas être la réponse du Canada à un manque de soins et de soutiens essentiels. Elle ne doit pas être la réponse du Canada à ceux qui souffrent. Il est inadmissible que l’AMM devienne accessible à des Canadiens dont la maladie même peut inclure des symptômes de désespoir et la conviction que leur situation ne changera pas pour le mieux; qui n'ont pas essayé tous les traitements raisonnables ou qui n'ont peut-être pas eu accès à un traitement. Nous vous demandons instamment de mettre un terme à l'expansion de l'AMM lorsque la maladie mentale est la seule condition médicale, qui entrera en vigueur en mars 2024. Nous vous prions d'agréer, Madame et Messieurs les ministres, l'expression de nos salutations distinguées, Julia Beazley Directrice, Public Policy Author: Julia Beazley

bottom of page