top of page
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • X

Search Results

Search this site

356 results found with an empty search

  • Letter to Senators on Bill C-7: Medically assisted death

    Dear Senator, I appreciate your service to our country and the Senate’s careful, considered approach to policy and legislative changes. Bill C-7 proposes watershed changes to law, medicine and society that require a careful and thorough study. The timing of these changes is troubling. They are being rushed through when we have yet to make real progress in ensuring high quality palliative care is available to all Canadians. We are in the middle of a pandemic when people with disabilities and chronic illness face even greater financial and medical challenges that undermine their ability to live with security. And procedural problems with the existing regime have been identified, but not yet addressed. I was one of the many witnesses who appeared before the Legal and Constitutional Affairs Committee in its pre-study of Bill C-7. The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada is deeply concerned about the changes to the assisted dying regime in Bill C-7 and its impact on those who are vulnerable. National disability rights organizations clearly and strongly oppose expanding access to euthanasia to persons who aren’t dying. Making hastened death available outside an end-of-life context—only to people with disabilities or chronic illness—is discriminatory. It puts persons with disabilities outside the protections offered to other Canadians. Bill C-7’s proposed removal of ‘reasonably foreseeable’ death is a significant change. The fact situation addressed in the Carter case was an end of life context. One of the stated objectives of the 2016 law (known as Bill C-14) sought to “…affirm the inherent and equal value of every person’s life and to avoid encouraging negative perceptions of the quality of life of persons who are elderly, ill or disabled.” This critical objective must not be set aside. The removal of the end of life criteria was prompted by the decision of one judge in Truchon and the decision was not tested by higher courts. The government can and should reintroduce an alternative, unambiguous end of life requirement to replace “reasonably foreseeable” death. If there is concern about the constitutionality of an end of life criterion, it could be tested by asking the Supreme Court to review its constitutionality. We remain firmly opposed to hastened death, but we offered these recommendations in our brief to the committee to minimize the harm and the risk of the legislation: introduce an end of life requirement to replace ‘reasonably foreseeable’ death maintain the exclusion of mental illness, but require assessment for concurrent mental illness delete the provisions that remove the mandatory 10-day reflection period, create a waiver of final consent and reduce the requirement from two independent witnesses to one witness who may be a paid caregiver extend the new safeguards proposed for those whose death is not foreseeable to also protect those whose death is foreseeable add specific conscience protection for health care workers and institutions in the Criminal Code It is essential to maintain these safeguards because research shows that people change their minds. The First Annual Report on Medical Assistance in Dying 2019 indicates that 263 patients withdrew their request for MAID in one year. The report indicates over half (54%) changed their minds and 26% found palliative care measures were sufficient. Of all the patients who withdrew their request, 20% withdrew their request immediately before MAID. The existing legislation already allows for the 10-day reflection period to be waived if the medical practitioners believe the person is likely to lose their capacity to consent or their death seems imminent. This important safeguard should remain in place, especially given that ‘foreseeable death’ is a subjective term without a clearly defined timeframe. In fact, in the Lamb case, it was suggested that ‘reasonably foreseeable’ could be very widely interpreted by medical practitioners to include people who may not die for years, if not decades. It is unconscionable that we would make it easier to access hastened death in Canada than it is to receive quality palliative care or for individuals living with disability to access the medical and social supports they need to enjoy living on an equal basis with other Canadians. We urge you to take the time and care this issue warrants. This legislation is too important to be rushed. We share some of the important commentary on Bill C-7 in the summary following this letter. I would be happy to discuss this issue further, if you wish, or to provide additional information. Sincerely, Julia Beazley Director, Public Policy The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada Author: Julia Beazley

  • Concern over Bill C-6 on conversion therapy

    The Hon. David Lametti Minister of Justice 284 Wellington Street Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0H8 Dear Minister Lametti, Many people who have experienced conversion therapy describe despair and suicidal ideation as a consequence. We recognize that initiatives to ban conversion therapy arise from a desire to protect Canadians from such damaging effects. Coercive and involuntary efforts to change sexual orientation have no place within our communities. Our community, however, has significant concern about the scope of the proposed legislation. We are particularly concerned with the definition of conversion therapy proposed in Bill C-6, which goes beyond efforts to change a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity, and includes practices, treatments and services to “repress or reduce… sexual behaviour.” There is concern that such a broad definition could infringe on religious expression, instruction and practice. An important aspect of religious identity is to learn and to share the teaching of sacred texts about how we should conduct ourselves in all areas of life, including human sexuality and sexual behaviour. Although the Justice Department summary says Bill C-6 would not criminalize “private conversations in which personal views on sexual orientation, sexual feelings or gender identity are expressed …” (emphasis added), no such exception is evident in the legislation itself. It is also unclear how the provisions in Bill C-6 may be applied to public religious instruction. If only exploratory conversations are exempted, will instruction or public expression, such as a sermon series or youth bible study on biblical sexual ethics, be construed as “a practice, treatment or service?” And since the definition of conversion therapy includes reducing sexual behaviour, could programs offered in a church or ministry setting that consider sexual activity and promote abstinence for all teens, regardless of orientation, be captured by the legislation? We are concerned that this legislation could, by imposing criminal sanctions, penalize and silence public speech and religious instruction on matters of sexuality and gender. Further, we note that the terms “practice, treatment or service,” while often used in a medical or therapeutic context, are not defined in Bill C-6 and can be interpreted and applied various ways. As written, these terms could include voluntarily sought out support groups for those who choose to live their lives in accordance with their religious beliefs. Many of these concerns with Bill C-6 could be alleviated by: deleting the final clause in the definition of conversion therapy, “to repress or reduce non-heterosexual attraction or sexual behaviour;” and clarifying in the exemptions that the following will not be considered conversion therapy: parental guidance on matters of gender or sexuality religious instruction on matters of gender or sexuality the private or public expression of sincerely held beliefs or views therapeutic or medical care offered to individuals voluntary seeking support. Canadians must continue to be free to order their sexual lives in accordance with their conscience, faith identity and personal convictions, and to voluntarily access support from their faith community, spiritual leaders, and others in doing so. Religious institutions must also remain free to teach and instruct their members and adherents in faithful practices that are part of the religious tradition. We would welcome further consultation on these points, and continued dialogue as this bill is considered. Sincerely, Julia BeazleyDirector, Public Policy Author: Julia Beazley

  • In support of pornography restriction Bill S-203

    Senator Miville-Dechêne Senate of Canada Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0A4 Dear Senator, The EFC is pleased to support Bill S-203 An Act to restrict young persons’ online access to sexually explicit materials. This bill will require commercial pornography sites to verify that consumers are adults in order to access their content. Such accountability is urgently needed. Mainstream pornography frequently depicts violent, degrading and dehumanizing sexual content. This content is freely and easily accessible by children and youth. We know kids are being exposed to this abusive content at increasingly younger ages, when they lack the ability to understand or process what they are seeing. Online pornography has become the primary sex educator of young people today. A growing body of research tells us that widespread access to and use of online pornography contribute to a broad range of harms, particularly to minors. Its impact on child psychosocial and sexual development and the way it is shaping sexual attitudes, behaviours and preferences, as well as the increase in compulsive behaviour and addiction related to viewing online pornography, constitute a public health crisis. Further, the proliferation and widespread consumption of online pornography fuels other forms of sexual exploitation, such as prostitution and human trafficking, and contributes to rape culture. Bill S-203 is an important initiative to set up crucial protection for minors from the harms of exposure to online pornography. We commend your efforts in bringing it forward and we will support its progression. I would appreciate the opportunity to meet with you to discuss this initiative further. Sincerely, Julia Beazley Director, Public Policy Note: More details on this bill at TheEFC.ca/S-203 Author: Julia Beazley

  • Submission on Proposed Calgary Bylaw Banning Conversion Therapy

    A Calgary City Council committee held hearings on a proposed bylaw to ban conversion therapy in May 2020. The EFC’s written submission to the committee noted that “coercive and involuntary efforts to change sexual orientation have no place in our communities” but expressed concern that the bylaw’s definition of conversion therapy is so broadly worded that it infringes on freedom of expression. The EFC urged the committee to amend the definition of conversion therapy and to clarify that the bylaw does not capture religious instruction, parental guidance and supportive services for individuals wishing to order their sexual lives in accordance with their religious conscience, faith identity and personal convictions. Download the pdf of the EFC’s submission. (Skyline photo courtesy Wikipedia.) Related resource Bill C-8: Criminal Code Ban on Conversion Therapy

  • Brief on COVID-19 to the Finance Committee

    In this submission to the parliamentary Finance Committee studying the government’s response to the Covid-19 pandemic, the EFC recommends (download PDF): additional flexibility in the Canada Emergency Wage subsidy, to allow charitable organizations to use a six or twelve-month period to calculate the decrease in their revenue exploring matching funds for charitable donations to a particular amount or for a certain period of time, excluding donations for capital projects. increased tax incentives for charitable giving, such as an increase in the charitable tax credit or removing the capital gains tax on donations of real estate or private company shares Related resources For church resources on Covid-19, see TheEFC.ca/Covid-19.

  • 2019 Church & Faith Trends Survey

    A major new EFC survey suggests half of Canadians are either agnostic, atheist or unreligious. And only a tenth attend religious services weekly. How will the church respond? The 2019 Church and Faith Trends Survey was conducted with 5,011 Canadians over the age of 18 August 12–16, 2019 on the Maru/Blue research panel. The survey was conducted in English and French. A detailed introduction to the survey and its results is included in the Jan/Feb 2020 issue of Faith Today magazine. Four pages are available free online, and four additional pages of reflection are only available to subscribers. This 2019 survey is a tracking poll on church and faith trends that builds on ones that the EFC and its partners have done in 2003, 2007, 2013 and 2015. Common to all these surveys is a set of 8 questions that make up the Christian Evangelical Scale (CES). http://www.faithtoday.ca/Magazines/2020-Jan-Feb/Not-Christian-anymore The CES is a way to track evangelical alignment in Canada over time developed by Maru/Blue pollster Andrew Grenville. (It is based on scholar David Bebbington’s four peculiar emphases for evangelical Christians including Biblicism, Crucicentrism, Activism and Conversionism. See Bebbington’s Evangelicalism in Modern Britain: A History from the 1930s to the 1980s pages 1-19 and Appendix A in “Evangelical Alignment in Canada” for more.) Every kind of measurement has its own limitations. Public opinion polling has its limitations, but so do individual questions or sets of questions. To better find “Evangelicals,” in addition to the CES questions we also asked questions about affiliation and whether respondents consider themselves to be Evangelical Christians. So, our three measures were: Evangelical Alignment: Do they score 28 or higher on the Christian Evangelical Scale? Affiliation: Are they affiliated with a church within the evangelical tradition? Evangelical self-identity: Do they consider themselves to be an Evangelical Christian? Chart 1, below, shows the how 2019 survey respondents answered these three questions. A future article will look compare the populations represented by the different areas on this chart. For now, we will observe the following: The evangelically aligned are about 11% of the population. Evangelical affiliates are about 6% of the population. Those who consider themselves to be Evangelical Christians are about 6% of the population. The combination of all these groups represent about 13% of the population. The complete list of survey questions are available as PDFs (English, French). Check back to this page for forthcoming articles based on the 2019 survey data on these and other topics: Tolerance. Results on this topic were part of a public presentation by Dr. Sam Reimer (March 10, 2020) Who is an “Evangelical”? Bible engagement A religious profile of gamers Canadian’s belief in a bodily resurrection. A good place to start is the four-page introduction available free online from Faith Today magazine. You can also read more about evangelicalism in Canada on the EFC's About Evangelicals webpage.

  • Lamb v. Canada [2019]

    The EFC was granted intervener status in the Lamb case in B.C., which involved attempts to expand access to assisted suicide and euthanasia. The case would have been argued before the Supreme Court of British Columbia. The EFC was intervening with the Christian Legal Fellowship. However, the Lamb case was adjourned in September 2019 because Julia Lamb has been approved for MAID (Medical Assistance in Dying). EFC-CLF Notice of Application to Intervene (Dec. 7, 2018) BC Civil Liberties Association notice of adjournment (Sept. 18, 2019)

  • P.T. et al v. Alberta [2018]

    Alberta passed Bill 24: An Act to Support Gay-Straight Alliances, in November 2017. The bill required school principals to immediately grant permission for Gay-Straight Alliance/Queer-Straight Alliance clubs or activities “intended to promote a welcoming, caring, respectful and safe learning environment that respects diversity and fosters a sense of belonging” at the request of a student. However the province has passed new legislation that does not include the provisions from Bill 24 that were at issue, effective Sept. 1, 2019. Concerns were raised because Bill 24 also amended the School Act to specify that, although parents are to be notified of instruction or exercises that deal explicitly and primarily with religion or sexual activity, there was to be no notice to parents about student participation in a GSA or QSA club or event. This meant that parents were not to be notified of student participation in a club or event, even for the youngest of students. Bill 24 also required all publicly-funded schools to develop a policy on bullying and a student code of conduct that must “respect diversity” and be approved by the province. A coalition of faith-based schools and parents in Alberta, with the help of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, launched a constitutional challenge of Bill 24 and an injunction to allow the faith-based schools to be exempt from the legislation until the constitutional challenge was heard. However, as a result of the reversal caused by the new legislation, this constitutional challenge will not proceed. What happened in the courts A lower court in Alberta heard a challenge in 2018 on the constitutionality of Bill 24 and the injunction request. It did not grant the injunction in its June 27, 2018 decision, but that decision was appealed. The EFC was given intervenor status in the appeal of the decision on the injunction. The EFC argued in support of parental rights and religious freedom. The Alberta Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal April 29, which meant there would be no temporary exemption for faith-based schools and others from Bill 24. In summer 2019 it looked like the constitutional challenge would go ahead, and the EFC applied once again for intervener status. But as a result of the reversal caused by the new legislation, the issue now appears closed. Download the EFC's legal arguments (factum, Alberta Court of Appeal) filed Nov. 5, 2018 Read a short Three Questions interview with our lawyer from Nov. 12, 2018 Sample letter designed for Albertans to send to their MLAs or the Alberta minister of education (.pdf or .docx)

  • Renegotiating Faith: Young Adult Transition Research

    A major new Canadian study looking at Christian young adults' transitions from high school to the next phase in life has begun publishing its findings in July 2018 online here . (And see the EFC's collection of related resources such as podcasts, webinars and Faith Today articles.) The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada, Power to Change–Students, InterVarsity Christian Fellowship, Youth For Christ and Truth Matters have partnered to discover how we can help our teens stay connected to church and faith as they move on from high school. The new study builds on the 2011 Hemorrhaging Faith study, which found major life transitions were often transitions out of church and faith for Christian young adults. The new 2018 study was initially known as the Young Adult Transition Research (YATR) study, but is more commonly referred to by the title of its first report, Renegotiating Faith: The Delay in Young Adult Identity Formation and What It Means for the Church in Canada . YATR is a major study for the whole Canadian church, and the research partnership worked cooperatively with Catholics, Mainline Protestants, Orthodox and Evangelicals. If you have any questions about the study please contact: Rick Hiemstra hiemstrar@theEFC.ca 613-233-9868 x332 Research on the Transition of Young Adults (RTJA) A major new Canadian study on the transition of young Christian adults from high school to the next phase of their lives began publication in July 2018 at RenegotiatingFaith.ca .(And check out our collection of related resources such as podcasts, webinars, and Faith Today articles .)The Evangelical Alliance of Canada, Power to Change Students, InterVarsity Christian Fellowship, Youth for Christ Canada, and Truth Ministries formed a research partnership to discover how we can help our teens stay connected to the church and the faith as they leave high school.The new study builds on the 2011 study Hemorrhaging Faith , which found that major life transitions were often transitions away from the church and faith for young Christian adults. The new 2018 study was originally known as YATR (Young Adult Transition Research), but it is more commonly referred to by the title of its first report, Renegotiating Faith: Impacts of Delayed Identity Formation Among Young Adults on the Church in Canada . (Download the French summary of Renegotiating Faith or visit RenegotiatingFaith.ca .)​​YATR is a major study for the entire Canadian church, and the research partnership worked collaboratively with Catholics, Mainline Protestants, Orthodox, and Evangelicals. If you have any questions about the study, please contact Rick Hiemstra at hiemstrar@theEFC.ca or 613-233-9868, ext. 322.

  • Trinity Western University School of Law [2013-2018]

    Here's the latest news including implications analysis by lawyer Geoffrey Trotter, podcast with TWU’s Bob Kuhn, EFC president’s blog and video, webinar discussion, news releases and more. Below this bulleted list is a series of buttons that allow viewing of additional material. Implications for the Evangelical Community of the Supreme Court Decision in the Trinity Western University Law School Case. By Geoffrey Trotter, co-counsel for the EFC in its interventions in the TWU law school litigation at all levels of court in British Columbia and at the Supreme Court of Canada (Sept. 11, 2018) EFC Podcast: Trinity Western's Controversial Community Covenant - With TWU President Bob Kuhn (Aug. 17, 2018) On TWU making its covenant optional for students: an EFC official statement (Aug. 16, updated Aug. 20, 2018) TWU Revisits Community Covenant: a statement from TWU (Aug. 14, 2018) Webinar recording: Unpacking the TWU Supreme Court of Canada decision. Guests: EFC President Bruce Clemenger, legal co-counsel Albertos Polizogopoulos, Justin Cooper of Christian Higher Education Canada (June 27, 2018) Making Sense of the TWU Court Decision, by EFC President Bruce Clemenger: Part One (on the majority decision, June 21, 2018), Part Two (on the dissenting opinion, June 22), Part Three (on the implications of the decision, June 22) Unpacking the TWU Decision: An Early Response From Earl Phillips of TWU Law School (audio podcast, June 15, 2018) TWU Disappointed (news release, June 15, 2018) EFC and CHEC Disappointed (news release, June 15, 2018) TWU decision ‘undermines’ freedoms: Archbishop (news release, June 15, 2018) EFC President Bruce Clemenger responds to Supreme Court decision (video, June 15, 2018) The Supreme Court decision in Law Society of British Columbia v. TWU (June 15, 2018) The Supreme Court decision in TWU v. Law Society of Upper Canada (June 15, 2018) Additional commentary articles are available below offering context on this important case The EFC continues to encourage supporters to pray for healthy religious freedom and for God’s blessing on all those affected by these issues and court cases. Issue Summary rinity Western University is a Christian university in British Columbia and an affiliate of the EFC. After TWU obtained all the formal approvals needed to start its own law school and grant degrees, provincial law societies in British Columbia, Ontario and Nova Scotia voted to create obstacles for such graduates wanting to practise law in those provinces, either by refusing to admit TWU law school graduates or not to consider TWU an accredited school. (Several other provinces including Alberta and New Brunswick have okayed future TWU law graduates.) Objections centre on the school’s Community Covenant, which has students and faculty pledge to abstain from certain activities and behaviours during their studies including the viewing of pornography, the possession or use of alcohol on campus, and “sexual intimacy that violates the sacredness of marriage between a man and a woman.” The EFC believes law societies that have voted not to accept TWU law graduates have overstepped their mandates and that such decisions violate the religious freedom of TWU and its graduates. TWU launched legal challenges in the three provinces where provincial law societies are refusing accreditation. Initial rulings in Nova Scotia, Ontario and B.C. led to appeal rulings. The EFC submitted joint interventions with Christian Higher Education Canada in each of these cases. The Supreme Court heard final appeals of the Ontario and B.C. cases Nov. 30 and Dec. 1, 2017. The EFC was one of the interveners permitted to appear in the case to support TWU’s right to hold to a community covenant. Records From The Final Hearings Read our live tweets from each day Watch the court presentation by Albertos Polizogopoulos, co-counsel for the EFC Watch full Supreme Court official footage of the hearings (Polizogopoulos appears at 25:40) EFC President Bruce Clemenger gave brief video updates on Day 1 and Day 2 of the hearings There’s also a videorecording of the hearings on CPAC News Articles Commentary Still seeking law school, Trinity Western drops sexual 'covenant' for students (National Post, Aug. 14, 2018; related stores at CBC.ca and Vancouver Sun) Canada’s First Christian Law School Pleads Case to Supreme Court (ChristianityToday.com, Nov. 30, 2017) TWU’s Battle for Religious Freedom Heats Up (Faith Today, Jul/Aug 2016) The FT Interview With Bob Kuhn, President of Trinity Western University, Faith Today, May/Jun 2014 (republished on the Faith Today blog, Dec. 15, 2014) Commentary Making Sense of the TWU Court Decision Part One, by EFC President Bruce Clemenger (blog post, June 21, 2018) Unpacking the TWU Decision: An Early Response From Earl Phillips of TWU Law School (audio podcast, June 15, 2018) TWU Disappointed (news release, June 15, 2018) EFC and CHEC Disappointed (news release, June 15, 2018) TWU decision ‘undermines’ freedoms: Archbishop (news release, June 15, 2018) Three Understandings of State Neutrality, EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger, April 2018 Checking in on the TWU law school case with EFC lawyer Albertos Polizogopoulos, March 2018 Competing Views on State Neutrality, EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger, Jan. 2018 Theological Lessons From the TWU Law School Case, EFC Vice-President David Guretzki, Dec. 2017 EFC Podcast interview with Janet Epp Buckingham, a lawyer who helped develop the original proposal for a law school at Trinity Western, Dec. 2017 The EFC and the Canadian Council of Christian Charities called for a national day of prayer for religious freedom on Nov. 26, 2017. Those prayers are still needed in these months while we await the decision of the Supreme Court. Popular Opinion or Legal Principle? TWU Case Heard in B.C., EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger, Aug. 2015 Ontario Decision on TWU Law School: Reflections on the Ontario Superior Court’s Decision in TWU v. LSUC, EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger, July 2015 Organizations Free to Maintain Religious Identity, EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger, Feb. 2015 Defending the TWU Dissenters, Marni Soupcoff in National Post, Jan. 2015 Protecting Minority Rights From the Majority, EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger, Nov. 2014 TWU Controversy: Implications for Other Christian Schools and Legal Precedents Support TWU. The May/Jun 2014 issue of the EFC magazine, Faith Today, has several related articles. Canadian Law Societies: Bastions of Intolerance?, Albertos Polizogopoulos, Jan. 2014 Religious beliefs and practices are constitutionally guaranteed, not “silly” or “stupid”, Don Hutchinson, Nov. 2013 Legal Submissions EFC and CHEC Legal Factum, Supreme Court of Canada, September 18, 2017 EFC and CHEC Legal Factum, British Columbia Court of Appeal, April 19, 2016 EFC and CHEC Legal Factum, intervention in a Aug. 24, 2015 judicial review in the British Columbia Supreme Court EFC and CHEC Legal Factum, intervention in a June 1, 2015 judicial review in the Ontario Divisional Court (written legal submissions from other groups in the case are available at outonbayst.org/about/media-news/twu/) EFC and CHEC Legal Factum, intervention in a Dec. 16-19, 2014 judicial review in the Nova Scotia Supreme Court, Oct. 2014 (written legal submissions from other groups in the case are available at nsbs.org/twu-public-input) Letters Law Society of New Brunswick, April 2014 Law Society of Upper Canada, March 2014 Nova Scotia Barristers' Society, Feb. 2014 Law Society of British Columbia, Feb. 2014 Toronto Star, Oct. 2013 Related Provincial Lower Court Cases British Columbia Case (LSBC v TWU) The Canadian Press reported Feb. 23, 2017 (National Post, Globe and Mail) that the Supreme Court of Canada has agreed to hear appeals of the Ontario and B.C. cases The appeal of the Dec. 10, 2015 ruling was heard in early June 2016, and a ruling was released November 1, 2016. The EFC released a news release the same day EFC and CHEC Legal Factum, British Columbia Court of Appeal, April 19, 2016 EFC media release: B. C. Supreme Court Restores Earlier Law Society Decision to Accredit Trinity Western Law School - 2015-12-10 Text of B. C. Supreme Court Decision in TWU v. Law Society of British Columbia (Dec. 10, 2015) EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger reflects on the case in an Aug. 25, 2015 article Joint submission of legal arguments by the EFC and Christian Higher Education Canada, submitted July 27, 2015: EFC-CHEC Legal Factum for B.C. Read a news release from TWU and its Law School Blog See related recent news from the Law Society of BC Nova Scotia Case (TWU v NSBS) The Nova Scotia Barristers’ Society has said it doesn’t plan to appeal further. The appeal was heard in early April 2016, and a ruling was released July 26. The EFC responded immediately. TWU previously received a strongly favourable court ruling in Nova Scotia on Jan. 28, 2015 which agreed with several arguments from the EFC Legal Factum EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger responded immediately with a news release and a commentary (blog post, Feb. 4, 2015): Organizations Free to Maintain Religious Identity Commentary from Jan. 28, 2015 by lawyer Albertos Polizogopoulos, who represented the EFC and Christian Higher Education Canada in the case The Courts of Nova Scotia offer recorded webcasts of the Dec. 16-19, 2014 intervention hearings at courts.ns.ca/Webcasts/webcasts_archive_trials.htm. 2015 articles from mainstream media: Times Colonist, Canadian Lawyer, CTV News, The Globe and Mail, CBC Ontario Case (TWU v LSUC) The Canadian Press reported Feb. 23, 2017 (National Post, Globe and Mail) that the Supreme Court of Canada has agreed to hear appeals of the Ontario and B.C. cases The Ontario Court of Appeal decision was released June 29, 2016 and the EFC responded. TWU has said it will appeal to the Supreme Court. On July 2, 2015 the Ontario Superior Court ruled against TWU in its dispute with the Law Society of Upper Canada. Although the three-judge panel concluded that “the decision of the [LSUC] does have the effect of interfering with [TWU’s] rights to religious freedom,”the court expressed its view that the infringement was “not unreasonable.” Responses to the July 2, 2015 ruling were released from TWU and from EFC President Bruce J. Clemenger (online reflection July 7, 2015) Read the joint submission of legal arguments by the EFC and CHEC: EFC-CHEC Legal Factum for Ontario See past media releases from the EFC and from TWU.

  • Ktunaxa Nation v. British Columbia [2016-2017]

    On Nov. 2, 2017, justices at the Supreme Court announced their decision in the Ktunaxa case, which they heard back on Dec. 1, 2016. The EFC intervened in the case, and here you’ll find an issue summary, analysis and links to media releases and legal arguments. Issue Summary (From 2016) For the first time, the Supreme Court of Canada was set to determine the merits of an Indigenous religious freedom claim under the Canadian Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms. This historic case raised serious concerns about third-party interests limiting and overriding religious freedom and the means by which religious communities can practise and manifest their faith. The Christian Legal Fellowship and The Evangelical Fellowship of Canada were joint interveners in the case, which arises from the proposed development of a ski resort on land that is sacred to the Ktunaxa people. The Ktunaxa Nation opposes the construction of the ski resort on the basis that it would desecrate the sacred site and would interfere with a variety of their spiritual practices. Ultimately, the B.C. Minister of Forests, Lands and Natural Resources approved the development but the Minister did not specifically address how the decision would impact the Ktunaxa Nation's section 2(a) Charter right to freedom of religion. Analysis of the November 2017 Court Decision The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled in a case called Ktunaxa Nation v. British Columbia, dealing with religious freedom and Indigenous rights. The Ktunaxa Nation opposed the development of a ski resort on their traditional territories – in particular in an area of land that is sacred to them – on the basis it would desecrate the sacred site and interfere with their spiritual practices. The EFC and Christian Legal Fellowship intervened in this case because it raised several important questions about religious freedom. First, this case asked whether government must consider a religious freedom claim made under section 2(a) of the Charter, which guarantees the fundamental freedoms of conscience and religion. Second, this case asked the court to clarify a lower court’s assertion that the guarantee of religious freedom in section 2(a) of the Charter does not protect religious expression that impacts a third party. And last, it asked to what extent the vehicles, instruments or means of expressing religious freedom are protected under section 2(a) of the Charter. In the decision the majority of the Supreme Court confirmed that the provincial minister making the decision about the land development should have considered the section 2(a) claim of religious freedom. The freedom – of individuals and communities – to hold religious beliefs and to manifest or express them in worship and practice, or by teaching and dissemination, should have been considered (according to paragraph 71 of their decision). However, the majority also concluded (in paragraph 60) that the minister’s failure to consider it was “immaterial” in this case, because the claim made by the Ktunaxa was outside the scope of the guarantee of freedom of religion in section 2(a) of the Charter. The freedom to worship does not protect the object of religious belief or the spiritual focal point of worship – in this case, the Spirit of the Great Bear. This was not unexpected, as the guarantee of freedom of religion in section 2(a) has consistently been used to guarantee the freedom to believe, not the beliefs themselves. The majority also reasoned (in paragraph 72) that to extend the interpretation of freedom of religion in section 2(a) to include protection of the object of belief would put deeply held personal or communal beliefs under judicial scrutiny, and would require the state and courts to assess the content and merits of religious beliefs. The court and other government bodies do not make judgments on the content of religious belief. This is significant in light of the Wall case, which the Supreme Court heard on November 2, the same day its decision in Ktunaxa was released. The Wall case was about whether the courts should review internal decisions relating to membership of religious organizations, or any private association. The case asked whether decisions about membership are matters of theology and doctrine, and whether in adjudicating those decisions the court becomes inappropriately involved in matters of religion. The Ktunaxa case was particularly challenging in that it reflects, at its core, a conflict of worldviews. Land is of deep significance to Indigenous peoples, and for many, land cannot be separated from belief and worship. For the Ktunaxa, the Spirit of the Great Bear, the object of their belief, resides in the valley in question. Ktunaxa knowledge keepers teach that the kind of development proposed for the valley would drive Grizzly Bear Spirit from the area. While the majority of the court did not comment on whether the protection of sacred spaces or places of worship is included in the freedom of religious expression guaranteed in section 2(a), the minority decision offered a more expansive view of freedom of religion. The minority opinion clearly recognized the significance of land to the Ktunaxa Nation, and to the practice and expression of their beliefs. It recognized (in paragraph 117) that development of the ski resort would desecrate the sacred land and sever the Ktunaxa’s connection to the land, and to Grizzly Bear Spirit. The minority, Justices Moldaver and Côté, found that there was a violation of freedom of religion under section 2(a) and interpreted the religious freedom guarantee in the Charter to include the protection of that which is essential to religious beliefs. However, they nonetheless concluded that the minister’s decision not to grant the Ktunaxa the right to exclude others from developing on the land was reasonable in these circumstances. Overall, the Ktunaxa decision is significant because it provides greater clarity and definition about what is and is not included in the Charter’s protection of religious freedom. This case also highlights the need for greater understanding in initiatives to promote reconciliation between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Canadians. The conflict of worldviews in this case demonstrates some of the real and significant differences of belief that must be recognized and acknowledged in order for reconciliation to take place. Respect for Indigenous belief and culture, which has not historically been extended, is essential for reconciliation to advance. Legal Submissions, Media Releases and More EFC legal arguments (factum) on the Supreme Court’s website Supreme Court's decision of Nov. 2, 2017 EFC media releases from Nov. 3, 2017 and Nov. 30, 2016 Faith Today news article from Nov/Dec 2016

  • Wall v. Judicial Committee of the Highwood Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses [2017-2018]

    EFC staff are pleased by the Supreme Court decision of May 31, 2018. The case concerns whether the court has the jurisdiction to review the membership decisions of religious communities and other voluntary associations. Randy Wall was a member of the Highwood Congregation of Jehovah’s Witnesses in Calgary, Alberta. He was disfellowshipped by the elders of his local congregation. Wall asked the court to undertake a judicial review of the elders’ decision to disfellowship him. He was experiencing an economic impact in his work as a realtor due to the decision. In the lower court decision, Justice Wilson ruled that he had jurisdiction to review the elders’ decision to disfellowship Wall. The Highwood Congregation appealed the decision. In the Court of Appeal, the majority ruled that courts have the jurisdiction to review the decisions of religious organizations, while a minority found the Highwood Congregation’s decision is not subject to judicial review. Historically Canadian courts have determined that they do not have jurisdiction in the internal decisions of churches and other private associations. For churches, decisions about membership and church discipline are matters of doctrine and the interpretation of Scripture. The courts have recognized that matters of doctrine and theology are beyond their expertise. The Supreme Court of Canada heard the case on November 2, 2017. The EFC argued it is important for religious communities to be able to define their membership and to protect their religious character, identity and integrity. The EFC co-intervened with the Catholic Civil Rights League. Related materials: Video: Bruce Clemenger comments on the May 31 Supreme Court decision, May 31, 2018. EFC Responds to Court Decision: Three questions on doctrine in the courts and the Wall case, May 31, 2018. Supreme Court of Canada decision, May 31, 2018. Watch a videorecording of the Nov. 2, 2017 hearing on CPAC. See the legal arguments from the EFC-CCRL intervention (and find some of the articles referred to in those arguments in the EFC-CCRL Book of Authorities), all filed October 2017. See the case summary on the Supreme Court website.

bottom of page